BOOK REVIEW: UNDERSTANDING MUHAMMAD, A PSYCHOBIOGRAPHY
Submitted by Sujit Das on Thu, 06/04/2009 - 08:27
Printer-friendly version
Send to friend
PDF versionBy Sujit Das
Title: Understanding Muhammad a Psychobiography (Paperback: 280 pages)
Author: Dr. Ali Sina
Date of publication: 1st May 2008, Second edition
Publisher: Felibri.com
While criticizing Islam, non-Muslims and ex-Muslims often tend to focus on the negative impacts of Islam; such as Islamic terrorism, fundamentalism, immense hate to non-Muslims etc, but in this book, the author, Dr. Ali Sina had gone far beyond. The central argument of this book is not about the dark side of Islam but the psychobiography of its founder, Prophet Muhammad.
Undoubtedly, Muhammad was a great leader. He fought many offensive battles, tortured, looted and killed innocent people and raped their women, assassinated his critics, ordered mass murder, addicted to pedophilia and reduced thousands of others into slavery in the name of God. His conduct was ungodly. But he also successfully twisted the sense of morality of his followers, distorted their sense of 'Humanness' and linked "doing good" and "a service to God" to all ungodly things. Briefly, he had given a sacred aura to crime and terrorism. Today what Bin Laden and his ideological brothers are doing is nothing more than what their Prophet had done centuries ago. It is too silly to believe this man a messenger of God.
Muslims often say, "We love death more than you love life". Presently nine out of ten ongoing conflicts worldwide involve Muslims. The author asserted [page 5] that Muslims are (as a group) 36 times more likely to resort to violence for conflict resolution than the rest of Humanity. Muslim's this type of behavior is not normal. Truly author affirmed, "To understand Muslims, one must understand their prophet". Unless we diagnose the cause of this problem like doctors and scientists, we cannot come to a solution.
This book is divided into seven well-planned chapters through which the author has analyzed Muhammad very skillfully and, with strength of evidence and force of reason proved that Islam is a dangerous cult, a cancer to Human civilization and a false belief system undeserving of existence. For probing deep into the strange mindset and psychological make-up of Muhammad, author has used several authentic Islamic sources; like, Bukhari and Muslim Hadith (oral traditions) and of course the Qur'an itself, and compared his findings with the modern development on psychotic and physical health studies. The author concluded that Muhammad was suffering from Narcissistic Personality Disorder and Temporal Lobe Epilepsy and "...these two conditions of personality and brain explain the entire phenomenon known as Muhammad" [page 6].
If the personality of a person is too rigid to the point that he is unable to change it in reaction to changing circumstances, we call it a personality disorder. A personality disorder is the ultimate misidentification. The individual mistakes his habits for his identity. Narcissism is a personality disorder that, as author quoted from the 'Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders', "revolve around a pattern of grandiosity, need for admiration, and sense of entitlement." [Page 60]
According to Dr. Sam Vaknin; a Narcissist is an actor enacting a melodrama, yet forced to remain behind the scenes. The scenes take the centre stage, instead. He is a denier of reality. He feeds off other people, who hurl back at him an image that he projects to them. This is their sole function in this world: to reflect, to admire, to applaud, to detest - in a word, to assure him that he exists. Otherwise, they have no right to tax his time, energy of emotions - so he feels. Narcissists are perceived to be sick, prone to illusions and delusions especially self delusions and, therefore, lacking in judgment [Vaknin; "Malignant Self Love: Narcissism Revisited", pp. 9, 19, 23].
Dr. Vaknin also mentioned that Narcissists are PATHOLOGICAL LIARS. This means that either they are unaware of their lies or feel completely justified and at ease in lying to others. Later they are bound to believe their own lies. Their very essence is a huge, contrived lie: the false self, the high-flying fantasies and the idealized objects. [ibid, p. 24]
Muhammad knew that a direct self-promotion would be seen as repulsive and hence would be rejected. So he invented his God, the Allah. In Islam, Allah took the centre stage and Muhammad remained 'only' a messenger of Allah. But at the same time Muhammad demanded absolute obedience by cunningly calling his followers to obey 'Allah and his messenger'. But since nobody could see or hear Allah, naturally all the obedience was to Muhammad. It was not God who needed Muhammad, but it was Muhammad who needed a God to serve him and certify him as a messenger.
Throughout his prophetic carrier, Muhammad never brought anything good to others but only death and destruction. He encouraged human sacrifice to his cause, ie, martyrdom. The Paradise is assured for the martyrs. But only belief in Allah is not enough to gain entry in the Paradise unless Muslims believe in the prophethood of Muhammad. So the religion of Muhammad survived at the cost of the 'liberal human values' of his followers. Unfortunately today more than a billion people still put their trust in Muhammad.
Muhammad hoped that the Jews of Yathrib will receive him as their Prophet. But the Jews paid little attention to his calling which made him angry and he sought revenge. The Narcissist Prophet forced the Qainqua and Nadir tribe into exile and mass assassinated some 800 to 900 male members of the Quraiza tribe and reduced their children and women to slavery. Muhammad, like other typical Narcissists could not feel the pain of others. He was a predator and just did not know what it meant to be Human. A Narcissist has no time or energy for anything except the next Narcissistic fix, no matter what the price and who is trampled upon. [ibid, p. 39]
The narcissist Prophet lacked in judgment. The biggest mistake Muhammad made was to invent an 'ungodly' God. He was in such a delusion that he could not even differentiate between a God and a Demon.
A Byzantine historian, Theophanes (752-817) recorded that Muhammad suffered from epilepsy, which started when he was just five years old. Author's findings from authentic Islamic sources confirm the opinion of the above historian. Amazingly, the Hadith collections have enough mention about Muhammad's epileptic fits. Today with the help of science, we can confirm that Muhammad suffered from Temporal Lobe Epilepsy and the epileptic seizures were caused from the medial or lateral temporal lobe. The patients of TLE often sense a 'presence', hear sounds, see divine lights even see 'Gods'. So when Muhammad claimed to have mystic experience, it was actually his diseased mind which was playing tricks to him. Hallucination is very common amongst people. The International Census of Waking Hallucinations recorded in 1984 that 10 to 25 percent of normal healthy people have experienced at least once in their lifetime a vivid hallucination [Carl Sagan; "The Demon Haunted World", page. 104]
Now since the sacred aura of the Prophet is gone and the big lie of Islam is fully exposed; the author very logically concluded, "Islam is like a house of cards, sustained by lies ... It rests on nothing but lies" [Pages, iv, 260]. We should not forget that narcissists are pathological liars.
Today it is useless to be angry with a deluded person like Muhammad who died centuries ago. He not only suffered in his whole life, but founded such a dangerous cult which brought untold misery, death and destruction equally to Muslims and non-Muslims, for which history will never forgive him. It was Muhammad's fate. He was gravely disturbed both physically and mentally. In fact he was also suffering from Acromegaly and most probably from Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD), Bipolar Disorder and even from Schizophrenia.
Now, since the real face of Muhammad is exposed by strong evidence, and medical science has spoken out the truth, and because we cannot see any difference between Islam and other notorious cults; it is high time, our Muslim brothers should give way to logical thinking. The author lamented "Muslims are genuinely incapable of questioning Islam" [page 5]. Today Muslims must understand that there is better life beyond Islam and the infidels (particularly the Jews) are not really that bad so that they should be killed as the Qur'an said. Real God has nothing to do with Islam, Allah, Muhammad and Qur'an altogether. The author himself is coming from Muslim background and some of his relatives were even Ayatollahs.
Author concluded, "Islam is an epidemic of mental illness bequeathed from one man to his followers" [Page 254]. The mental sickness of Muhammad implanted to his followers has cost hundreds of million lives, "The wounds caused by Muhammad and his benighted followers have been bleeding for 1400 years. They are still bleeding and will continue to bleed endlessly, until Islam is eradicated." [Page 255]
The author wrote this book mainly for the Muslims and had two aims in mind - to help Muslims see the truth and leave Islam en masse and to unmask the real face of Islam and warn the world of its threat.
The cover page is thoughtfully designed and it speaks in volume. It shows Muhammad's first spiritual experience with Gabriel, which was actually a hallucination. The title perfectly explains the subject matter. If I simply say that the book is well written, it is an underestimation. All I can see is an overflow of systematic research and a tremendous force of logic backed up by strong evidence. Throughout the pages, the author had left marks of his exceptional clarity of thought and strong analytical capability. But he had done it without any pretended scholarship. The book is written in a very simple but extremely meaningful English. Author is thoroughly sincere, insightful, honest, straightforward and practical in expressing his views and had spoken his heart out. I strongly recommend this book to the readers. This book has fascinated me and will fascinate the casual readers, critics and scholars alike. It needs great courage to write a book like this. In fact I am waiting eagerly for author's next project.
The printing and binding quality of this paperback edition and the paper used are reasonably above standard in comparison to cost. The typography does not strain the eyes of the readers. The overall style of the book as a product is quite user-friendly.
Sooner or later, this book is going to make history. Already the sale is impressive and the book is translated to other languages. For any logical-minded reader Islam will not be the same as before. I sincerely believe, one day the Muslims will care for this book more than they care for Qur'an. In the coming years, the book will liberate a large number of Muslims from the Islamic prison. This book is going to outlive Islam.
Mr Jah: you are quoting Gita
Mr Jah:
you are quoting Gita out of context. here disbelief means not religion or god but dharma of life. it means one who does not respect human value and its dharma will suffer and perish and not the way you have referred it to be. you need to read mahabharat fully to understand gita and its meanings.
JAH, Say Mr rb tries to rape
JAH,
Say Mr rb tries to rape your wife and had attemted to murder you, will you say dont do any thing.
Krishna even asked for 5 villages for 5 brothers of pandva, but kaurva (like muslims) told no we will not give you anything. They tried to murder Arjuna and his brother many times. Say if you come to attack us then what will be our reaction, here come dharma, we have to attack you and kill you.
All muslims should role back to Arabia and drink piss.
The mullah brigade completely
The mullah brigade completely destroys the brain of these muslims, if a solder will not fight for the safety of his nation, his or his families honour then who will???
In hindu tradition there are many codes of conduct of war, not to hurt or attack peasants, women , children. But these donkey muslims from the start of there desert robberer have attacked women, and enslaved raped including children, and gives them '72' virgins if straight and 28 male child if gay.
Please dont insult donkeys by
Please dont insult donkeys by saying donkey moslems! donkeys and pigs have more brains than moslems.The moslems are utterly, completely and absolutely stupid.Comparing them to pigs and donkeys is an insult to the pigs and donkeys.Thank you
www.ahmedandsalim.com
www.ahmedandsalim.com
JAH, yes you need to read the
JAH, yes you need to read the whole passage. As pathfinder stated, Krishna said many of these things in reference to the masses of evil that were causing all sorts of chaos in the world back then (sort of like the Muslims now). Think about it what you just quoted and reference it towards the Taliban or Al Quida.
Now doesn't it make sense?
Jah, per your reference
Jah, per your reference to:
Whatever is done without faith - whether it is sacrifice, charity, austerity, or any other act - is useless. It has no value here or hereafter, O Arjuna.” (Gita 17.28)
Keep in mind in those days, "Hindus" had never encountered any other religion.
Jews and Pagans only existed in those days and both groups were too far away from the Indian subcontinent for "Hindus" of the time to encounter them or interact with them. Christianity and Islam had not been born, nor most of the other religions.
The reference of Gita 17:28 was those who believed in good deeds and doing the right thing or dharma as rb referred to in his explanation, or the disbelievers who where usually the evil lords and their thugs chausing chaos and disharmony.
I suggest before you start attacking the Gita and Hinduism, understand the historical context in which these events happend, and also cross reference to the Vedas and Upshanidas. The Gita in itself, if you do not know or understand Indian history or philosophy, will not be understood. It is not black and white, like your Quran is.
And just for the record, the Gita could not have stole any Quranic verses, because ISLAM WAS NOT EVEN BORN THEN.
moslems are 1.Compulsive
moslems are
1.Compulsive liars.
2.Brain dead zombies.
3.Stupid.
4.Idiotic
5.Followers of the pedophile rapist mohammad maha loud ah.
6.Daughter in law worms.
7.Arab Arse liclers.
8.Absoultely filthy, uncaring and cruel people.
8.Moslems are less than animals. So discussing with animals the virtues of life of compassion and love makes no sense.
To Jah, Gita 11:32 - 34:
To Jah,
Gita 11:32 - 34: http://www.bhagavad-gita.org/Gita/verse-11-32-02.gif
Do you know sanskrit. Suppose you know. then why you are mistransalating it. Your last hope to equate satanic verses of quaran with hindu scripture. thats a joke!
Now, let me translate the verse from gita, I am [aham (asmi)] time [kalo'] , destroyer of all beings in all worlds, engaged to destroy all beings in this world; those heroic soldiers sitting there in the opposing army, even without you none will be spared.
details: http://www.bhagavad-gita.org/Gita/verse-11-30.html
Yes, time is mass murderer. Every second thousands and thousands of living things die. None will be spared from grasp of time. Is not that obvious? Will not you die when your time arrives? You will be emerged to krishna! Face it.
@kksbig77 “yes you need to
@kksbig77
“yes you need to read the whole passage. As
“Think about it what you just quoted and reference it towards the Taliban or Al Quida. Now doesn’t it make sense?”
Yes, it does make sense when it comes to Hinduism. But when it comes to Islam, brain-dead Hindutwa fanatics are not able to realize the fact that the apparently war verses in the Quran are directed to Bajrang Dal and RSS terrorist and extremist like people. Understood?
__________________________________________________________
Your entire concept of hinduism and bhagavad gita is wrong. In this case you are the brain dead.
[quote]pathfinder stated, Krishna said many of these things in reference to the masses of evil that were causing all sorts of chaos in the world back then (sort of like the Muslims now).”
No reference has been produced yet.[/quote]
What reference you need? Why great war of Mahabharata happened? Because of chaos and evil deeds by kauravs. They killed anybody who came their way of getting the kingdom [remember 100 brothers of sakuni?] and in that context only Krishna said that. Unlike islam, there is no concept of kafir and apostate in hinduism.
Gita does not spread hate and violance against kafir, jews and christian and apostates like quaran.
You have claimed Gita stole verses from quran? Anothet Taquiya? Are you so stupid that you don't know Bhagavad gita is thousands of years older than Islam?
To Jah, Gita 11:32 - 34:
To Jah,
Gita 11:32 - 34: bhagavad-gita[dot]org/Gita/verse-11-32-02[dot]gif
Do you know sanskrit. Suppose you know. then why you are mistransalating it. Your last hope to equate satanic verses of quaran with hindu scripture. thats a joke!
Now, let me translate the verse from gita, I am [aham (asmi)] time [kalo'] , destroyer of all beings in all worlds, engaged to destroy all beings in this world; those heroic soldiers sitting there in the opposing army, even without you none will be spared.
details:bhagavad-gita[dot]org/Gita/verse-11-30[dot]html
Yes, time is mass murderer. Every second thousands and thousands of living things die. None will be spared from grasp of time. Is not that obvio
JAH, Its obvious you are a
JAH,
Its obvious you are a Muslim, and as such you have the right to your opinions. However you started this attack on Hinduism, and perhaps understandably so because a Hindu (Sujit Das) critiqued Ali Sina book and was in agreement with it. Therefore I can understand your compulsion to counterattack, as with my compulsion to defend the Dharmic (Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, Jain, Ayyavazhi, Santal) people's beliefs.
Ali's forum was started by Ali and his possee who are all ex-Muslims to educate the remainder of non-Muslims how dangerous Islamic ideology is. You attacking Hinduism only proves Ali's many points. I do not wish to debate religion to determine who is right, who is wrong, what was in context what was out of context, etc etc. I have made my position clear in the above posted comments. I have the right to belief as I wish, as do you.
I also believe Islam is a dangerous ideology because I have read the Quran (just as you are reading the Gita) and the Hadiths and I have come to my own conclusions. Furthermore I have experienced Islamic terrorism and lost members of my family as a result of such terrorism. Islamic terrorism throughout the world (and in India, as you point out VHP, RSS, etc.) is being faced by people of all different faiths, including Muslims themselves.
Right or wrong, if the Jaamat-ul groups can exists and as you know many of them are hardcore terrorists in India, then so too the Sangh Pariwar (VHP, RSS, etc) exist. Obviously there are good and bad elements in the Sangh Pariwar and for the most part the extremists are usually punished for their lack of respect for Dharma. Obviously the Sangh Pariwar exists to this day because Dharmic people feel the need to be protected from external threats (whatever or whomever those threats eminate from). And I'm sure as you know members of the Buddhists, Sikhs, Jains, Santhals, and Ayyavzhis communities also are member of the Sangh Pariwar. The problem with calling the Sangh Pariwar a terrorist organizaition is they have come to the aid of the Jewish community and Zoroastrian (Parsi) community in many occasions, and ironically even in some states the Christian community (go figure). Even several Muslim girls who faced rape from members of their own community several months back, and not too recently a Muslim boy who wanted to intermarry a girl of another religion were given protection and support by the bajrang dal. So while the media and the public at large and Islamists take issue with the Sangh Pariwar, one must bear in mind they have performed good deeds despite all the negativity they have recieved. You must ask yourself has the Jamaat groups also aided persons of other communities, or have the good deeds of the Jamaat only been confined to Muslims? I think we both know the answer to that.
If you choose to believe in Islam and that is a religion of peace and so on and so forth and shed Hinduism in a negative light, then so be it.
Some xxxx xxxxfanatics like
Some xxxx xxxxfanatics like idolater thought that I have mistranslated Gita’s verse. lol. They are caught red handed. They never read their own holy book, and now become horrified seeing the cruelty and mass-murder in Gita. Here is the source of Gita’s translation by Hindu guru:
http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/gita/agsgita.htm
He has admitted that Gita contains Satanic verses!
____________________________________________________________
Ha ha Jah, i assumed it correct. You don't know sanskrit. Neither you have gone through gita ever. I have real gita written in sanskrit on my table.
I have given you again the orginal verse in Quaran, it is here: bhagavad-gita[dot]org/Gita/verse-11-32-02[dot]gif
Its Kaal means time. Krishna claimed himself time and said that everything has to be vanished over the time.
I said "unlike Quran" not "like Quran", otay? You are xxxx as well as terrible xxx and xxxx.
Editor's Note to all: Can we please be more civil. Use polite language. Do not insult others. Discuss things in a rational manner. Just treat others like you want to be treated.
original verse in Gita*
original verse in Gita*
The indian moslem is an arab
The indian moslem is an arab arse licker.When he finishes doing this job for arabs in a nice way and presents his 6 year old daughter to arab mullah aged 60, he will find time to rape his own daughter inlaw and then he completes the sunnah of the rapist pedophile and then he will be guaranteed a virgin camel in the jannat as non arab moslems are inferior to arabs moslems.He is not only brain dead but he is inferior animal from india.Grow up animal
bro sina please please send
bro sina please please send me your book. pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasssssssssssssssssse. please please.i dont have credit card.
(we are not allowed credit cards in my family as it is haram) kkkkk.
please bro sina am begging ya please just one copy.i think you know my ???
please bro.please .cant wait.thanks.please can ya??
your biggest fan
bro sina is it ok if i
bro sina is it ok if i translate /print some of your works and articles in somali???i have friends still back home and yes ya big secretly in mogadishu my friend.ooh my god we love ya bro.
(ibrahim my kashmiri bro,yes there are thousands of ayaan hirsi bro.by the way ayaan means "lucky" in somali.we also have many ibrahims like ya kkkk let me just say to ya like the jamaicans say "soon come man,SOON.
JAH is once again proving
JAH is once again proving himself a master of fulfilling almost every logical fallacy known to man.
Keep it up, Muslim. You are only providing us with a great education on the kinds of logical fallacies that Islamic dummies commit, and thus providing us with more power and knowledge on how to shut down such baseless arguments and use them to educate other misguided Muslims away from Islam in the future. Class act!
@JAH Congratulations for
@JAH
Congratulations for reading Bhagavad Gita. I feel sorry about poisoned state of mind that you could not pick anything out of it. It takes several life times for ignorants like you to be able grasp teachings of Bhagavad Gita. Never mind going back to read again. There is simple Hindu therapy to cure poisoned mind. Chant "Hare Rama Hare Krishna".
Mr.Jah , Your mind is out of
Mr.Jah ,
Your mind is out of your brain,
I have seen you have misquoted the 11:32 verse despite three posts with screenshot of the verse was given by me. Face the truth man. Why you run away from truth?
Hindu believes in reincarnation.2:26-27 verse is damn true. What related to genocide, killing and such violent thing is there? Can you point out?
Verse 1:47, sanjay said so. Ok, so what? Arjun was feeling sad, is that demonic? LOL! May be that can be demonic for you because Prophet muhammad did not feel sad before killing thousands and thousands of innocent people.
“The evil doers, the ignorant, the lowest persons who are attached to demonic nature, and whose power of discrimination has been taken away by divine illusive power (Maya) do not worship or seek Me.”
Completely agree. Whats wrong with this verse?
Its useless to discuss sense
Its useless to discuss sense with muslim cretins like JAH. They are from childhood taught to read and understand everything in a twisted way.
Arabic is the only language written from right to left.
One simple example, take the case of North and South Korea , I am not taking the example of Isreal-Palestine. Whose government is good and whose people are happy? A normal human being will say South Korea, but may be muslim will say North Korea. Now if North Korea attacks and South Korean soldier will say we will not fight let them take all of south korea. Isnt it foolish? Here come dharma or Good justice, which Gita preaches to fight for honour to defend nation and to finish the evil.
There is no spoil of war concept where your lecher muhhamed and your brothers rape women, take children prisoner etc.
Time is changing non-muslims have to become like muslim fanatics and finish the idiots like you and properly train others and de toxify the mind of several innocents. Mullahs or fanatics like you should be jailed for ever.
Ali Sina correctly say there are some cretins like you who after reading so much in FFI, islam watch are still clinging to evil so there are no cure, who are like rabbid dogs where no vaccination will work.
You cant read and understand what is good and what is bad comparing Gita with quran is like comparing flower with pig shit.
Read the following article:
http://koenraadelst.bharatvani.org/articles/irin/PakiComeHome.html
and also
http://koenraadelst.bharatvani.org/articles/hinduism/wahi.html
@Jah, You are a joke, a
@Jah,
You are a joke, a nitwit, a boob, an imposteur, and a complete and total ignoramus.
Your mind is in HELL with your soul.
The above quotations from Bhagavad Gita are WONDERFUL, sublime, INSPIRED and the truth directly from God above.
But, because you have consigned to hell-fire, your mind is closed and grace, freedom, hope and faith in a heavenly afterlife have been denied to you.
Shame on you!!! You cannot even defend your cult of SATAN.
In the end you will be roasted in the hellfire with muhammad and all his minions.
Guys, leave JAH alone... let
Guys, leave JAH alone... let him live and drown in his ignorance... ignorance is bliss...
For those who do not know what Sanskrit word is translated as faith, it is "Shraddha", which actually means sincerity and self-honesty, rather than faith. This means doing your duty, charity etc. with no expectation of any kind and only as your duty.
JAH, This website have
JAH, This website have nothing to do with hinduism. We are debating whether Islam is correct or not.We should confine ourself at the discussion about Islam,mohammad,quran and current situation of the world. There may be many mistake found in the Gita,But it will not justify the evil teaching of Mohammad.You are trying to divert the topics of discussion.If you are so sure about the purity of Islam then why are you not using the text of Islam?why are you willingly use the other scriptures? Is it prove Islam correct?
Terrorism, War, Killing, and
Terrorism, War, Killing, and Genocide in holy Vedas
In Rig Veda III:34:9 Indra killed the Dasyus (dark skinned natives) and "gave protection to the Aryan color." Not only did the Aryans shamelessly pray for booty in war but they based their militarily won supremacy on the lightness of their skin color compared to the dark colors of the native Dasyus. They arrogantly proclaim, "Let those who have no weapons suffer sorrow." (Rig-Veda IV:5:14)
VERY TOLERANT VEDIC-HINDUS!
"Renowned is he when conquering and when slaying: 'tis he who wins cattle in the combat. When Indra hardens his indignation all that is fixed and all that moves fear him. Indra has won all kine, all gold, all horses, - Maghavan, he who breaks forts in pieces." (Rig-Veda IV:17:10-11)
Indra is praised for killing thousands of the abject tribes of Dasas with his arrow and taking great vengeance with "murdering weapons." (Rig-Veda IV:28:3-4) One hymn mentions sending thirty thousand Dasas "to slumber" and another hymn sixty thousand slain. A hymn dedicated to the weapons of war (Rig-Veda VI:75) refers to a warrior "armed with mail," using a bow to win cattle and subdue all regions, "upstanding in the car the skillful charioteer guides his strong horses on whithersoe'er he will." The arrows had iron mouths and shafts "with venom smeared" that "not one be left alive." Hymn VII:83 begins, "Looking to you and your alliance, O ye men, armed with broad axes they went forward, fain for spoil. Ye smote and slew his Dasa and his Aryan enemies."
The basic belief of the prayers and sacrifices is that they will help them to gain their desires and overcome their enemies, "The man who, sacrificing, strives to win the heart of deities will conquer those who worship not." (Rig-Veda VIII:31:15)
Furthermore, the prayers for riches continue, and Indra is thanked for winning wealth in horses, cattle, and gold by his chariot. Agni helps to slay the many in war by the hands of the few, "preserving our wealthy patrons with thy succors, and ourselves." (Rig-Veda I:31:6, 42)
Indra helped win the Aryan victory: "He, much invoked, hath slain Dasyus and Simyus, after his wont, and laid them low with arrows. The mighty thunderer with his fair-complexioned friends won the land, the sunlight, and the waters." (Rig-Veda I:100:18)
Control of the waters was essential for agricultural wealth. Indra is praised for crushing the godless races and breaking down their forts. (Rig Veda I:174)
Again, the ‘tolerant’ & ‘holy’ scriptures speak!
In the tenth and last book of the Rig-Veda some new themes are explored, but the Dasyus are still condemned for being "riteless, void of sense, inhuman, keeping alien laws," and Indra still urges the heroes to slay the enemies; his "hand is prompt to rend and burn, O hero thunder-armed: as thou with thy companions did destroy the whole of Sushna's brood." (Rig-Veda X:22)
More war, killing, and spoils in Vedas … (Rig-Veda 3:31:22; Rig-Veda 2:12:3-9; Rig-Veda 3:12:6; Rig-Veda 6:27:5; etc.)
Ah! So much peace and love in holy Vedas! Hindutwa fanatics are ignorant about their own holy books. They are only taught in their Ashram how to preach lies and extreme hatred against Islam, Christianity, Sikhism, Buddhism, and their followers.
Excellent article.
Excellent article.
JAH is 100 % Pakistani as
JAH is 100 % Pakistani as these kind of filmsy news are always available in taliban type news in Pakistan. For trying to manage the different ethnic groups in pakistan they always print false news.
Muslims always kill sikhs and tried to create anmosity between hindus and sikhs using propaganda machine.
Recent news:
These guys believe that Taliban is made by India or Hindus.
These guys believe that Pakistan is week, poor because of India/Hindus.
These guys believe that Jews did 9/11
These guys believe that all terrorist activity is US done.
They listen more to Taliban type news etc.
There is no enmity between Hindus with any other group. India is 80 % hindus but some facts:
Prime minister is Sikh.
2 Presidents of India were Muslim. Abdul Kalam is hardly muslim, he considers Gita as the greatest book. See the Link: http://www.vepachedu.org/kalam1.html
Actually Pakistani muslims are the product of the forced or raped offspring of earlier hindus, but now they are so much away from the roots that they are clueless.
Ask youself:
1. Why Quran is the most hated book in the world. Can you find critisism of Bhagwat Gita anywhere?
2. Why Muslims are very much hated in the whole world like Shit?
3. Why all muslims countries are poor?
4. Why maximum inbreeding propblem in muslims?
5. Why so many sites doing critical analysis of muslims?
6. Why 95 % of the world problem is due to muslims?
7. Why muslims kill muslims more expecially shia , sunni, bahai, ahmediya etc.
8. Why no innovation from 1.2 billion pigs like you?
9. Why so many people have to die for so called blasphemy like salman rusdie, Ayan hirsi ali, wafa sulatan, ibn warraq, nooni darwish etc.
10. Why so many writers , critical thinkers from muslims world are killed?
11. Why your faith is so week that you have to give death as official punishment for blasphemy?
Please go read more , develop some critical thinking, develop some questioning ability and then come to such forums.
Why dont you you ask your father/ mullah to defend your faith in this forum while unnecessarily coming here and pasting gibberish copied from taliban symapthied sites.
In most of the pakistan news
In most of the pakistan news every world incident is blamed on India, even if they get a cold, While palestinians blame Israel.
They will blame everything except Islam.
These guys believe that
These guys believe that Pakistan is week, poor because of India/Hindus.
Not so dear Naji Kafir,
Muslims (Pakistani or not) do NOT believe so, they know so.
How dare Naji Jews, Hindus and Jains and Sikhs deprive the allah given right of Mooslims to loot you dirty kafirs and rape your wives? This is oppression f Muslims. You better follow the advice of Gandu, who asked your women to spread their legs for Muslims, until the holy warriors of allah are satisfied.
Recent news: Muslims world
Recent news:
Muslims world wide,
1, "Christian, Hindu and Sikh families have been forced to flee because the Taliban imposed on them Jizia, a tax levied on non-Muslims living under Islamic rule," said Catholic Archbishop, Lawrence John Saldanha, in a letter released by the Catholic Bishops' Conference of India. "Now minority communities in the province are forced to endure unemployment, intimidation and migration," continued the Archbishop's message.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/05/18/christian-women-face-unkn_n_204...
In malaysia Muslim malays are so untalented that they have established a system called 'bhumiputra' where by hard working hindus and christians get less benefit while muslims gets special benifits.
In egypt copts are officially harassed.
Paklistan and China are working together and they are trying very hard to destablize india , but although being a hindu majority place they have given special benifits to muslims and christians. But muslims as always try to destroy the same house in which they live.
Also read the Islam history in Indian sub continent here:
http://www.historyofjihad.org/india.html?syf=contact
Most recently thank god India helped bangladesh Hindus,otherwise pakistan muslims are going to kill the highest number of people in a year even shaming Hitler see the site
http://www.genocidebangladesh.org/
They killed 30, 00, 000 unarmed civilians, raped 4,00,000 women. cut the hands of 10,000, cut the breast of thousands, gouged the eyes of the people.
In kashmir they destroyed the hindus homes and forced some 4,00,000 hindus from there home.
After the soviet defeat , Pakistan used the islamic terrorists against India. In kashmir shias and hindus in particularly were targeted.
See the site and the crimes done by Muslims:
http://ikashmir.net/atrocities/index.html
@JAH, You have taken a lot
@JAH,
You have taken a lot of pain to dig around Hinduism. Unfortunately you have not compiled a complete page even after twisting and tampering. But we at FF acknowledge your hard work. You can have extra pitcher of camel urine tonight and dream about your Prophet Muhammad licking ass of 72 houris. Don't forget to publish your next research work. We have lined up surprise gift for you in line with your Islamic tradition. Peace...
Here is some bad news for
Here is some bad news for Hindus, Sikhs, and Christians of Pakistan
Hindus in Pakistan agree to pay jazia to Taliban
04/06/2009 11:09:16
Islamabad: In May, dozens of Sikhs living in the Orakzai agency were forced to move out after the Taliban demanded Rs50 million as jazia, or security tax, from them. Locals said the families were impoverished and left the area to avoid any Taliban action.
Less than a month later, the tax net has spread wider, to the Khyber agency tribal area. The Sikhs, Hindus, and Christians there have been told by the Taliban-backed Lashkar-e-Islam (LeI) to pay jazia in exchange for ensuring their security in the area.
Having already imposed the security tax on non-Muslims in the Orakzai agency in the tribal belt on the Afghanistan border, the Taliban forces in this area have empowered the LeI to charge the tax on their behalf, Khyber agency sources said.
The LeI commander has publicly announced that Sikhs and Hindus will be free to live anywhere in the area after paying this protection tax.
Reports suggest that most of the minority community members in the region have agreed to pay the tax instead of leaving the area, having lived there for decades.
Sources said several jirgas (meetings of elders) were held to settle the issue. One such meeting held last week, attended by the leaders and elders of the Sikh, Hindu, and Christian communities at Tirah Valley, resulted in the decision to pay up rather than move out.
Women, children, and handicapped persons have been exempted from paying the tax, which amounts to Rs1,000 per head annually.
The LeI militants have already started collecting jazia in Bara, Chora, Karamna, Bazaar Zakhakhel, and Tirah Valley of Khyber agency. Those refusing to pay, or not in a position to pay, are being forced to leave.
MUSLIMS CANNOT LIVE WITHOUT
MUSLIMS CANNOT LIVE WITHOUT HEATHEN CULTURE
Green laddoos !!
02/06/2009 11:16:01 GSK Menon
When Shri.E.Ahmed took over as Minister of State in Railways, the Muslim League workers distributed Green coloured laddoos to celebrate the event ! To what extent can fundamentalism go to ?
The Muslim Leaguers forgot that Laddoo is a traditional Hindu sweet offering to their Gods & Goddesses. Why did they distribute a Hindu dish ? Could they not have distributed Camel meat or other Moplah dishes ? This is what these converts fail to realise, whatever alien religion they opt for, ultimately they have to depend on Hindu culture and traditions for daily needs.
Are they all not telling "namaskaram' to one another ? What does it mean ? It means I recognise and bow to the 'Paramatma' who is residing in you as the 'Jeevatma'. Is there any Paramatma or Jeevatma in Islam ?
If they are so obsessed with green colour we would like to know whether they are having green blood in their veins?
In Pakistan newspaper 'dawn'
In Pakistan newspaper 'dawn' comes up with nice writeups.
"Here is very imteresting point:
According to a March, 2009 report on DawnNews, a majority of people in the troubled Bajaur area wanted the implementation of the shariah law.
The same report then suggested that more than 70 per cent of the people residing in Bajaur are illiterate.
Now the question is how is one to respond to a demand made by an illiterate majority? "
http://blog.dawn.com:91/dblog/2009/06/04/the-frozen-solution/
Luckily with the formation of national boundaries muslims cant do there muhammed guided raids and so are forced to think of macroeconomic policy, water distribution or fiscal budgets but this beyond there means , then want to speak "Allah ya madat " live in poverty, do less brain work, beat women do sex and live a cave culture life.
JAH, just don't quote the
JAH, just don't quote the verses of the Gita out of context. The Gita is a part of the Mahabharatha, and it has to be interpreted according to context.
Krishna urged Arjuna to fight only after all efforts to make peace with the Kauravas failed.
Also, Krishna did not advocate fighting to spread religion. He advocated fighting to establish Dharma, which is a common code of conduct irrespective of who worshipped what god.
In any case Krishna did not preach in the Gita to grab the properties of slain soldiers. Nor did he preach to rape the widows of the slain soldiers. He certainly did not make sex and violence as motives for establishing Dharma !
But certainly, your prophet (piss be upon him) certainly did. He spread islam only with the twin incentives of sex and violence. Now that violence is met with reactive violence, muslims are finding it difficult to cope with the world.
Yes, muslims will find it difficult to adhere to their religion amid the resistance. That day will happen soon, and you, JAH, will find your muslim arse on fire.
Reading most of the comments
Reading most of the comments above is sadly depressing. Once again we see the same old distraction over and over again on this otherwise excellent site.
Again and again we witness an excellent article being ignored and side-lined by a jihadi scumbag spouting his usual off-topic ignorant rubbish about Hinduism and an entire chorus of Hindus loyally and predicably leap to its defence. It is like waving a red flag in front of a bull. The same happens when Christianity is insulted. This is so boring.
Moderators should ruthlessly delete all off-topic comments. It is impossible to conduct an intelligent discussion of an article when people allow themselves to fall for this old jihadi trick over and over again.
Similarly all sensible on-topic comments by readers are similarly buried under an avalanche of insults and counter-insults.
This is the only reason why I now post comments so rarely as compared to the past. It similarly discourages other of my friends from commenting and voicing their opinions. Do any other readers feel the same about off-topic comments?
Nice battle going on out over
Nice battle going on out over there.
So the time has come, when
So the time has come, when the Muslim pigs want to study Geetha and learn the art of killing innocents? Their pedo. Prophet Mo could taught them through Qu'rand - only the sadistic techniques of mass killing : never the art of killing. Hahahaha----
My suggestion for the Muslim
My suggestion for the Muslim pigs like JAH ; If you want to become human beings: you pigs should study Ramayana and Mahabharata to learn more about the art of mass killings.
Your book of prostitution Qu'rand was written by an uneducated uncultured pedophile criminal called MoHamMad. Who had no knowledge about the arts and science of killing.
On the other hand the authors of Ramayana and Mahabharata were philosophically, literally and spiritually highly learned and enlightened seers .
Mere readings of the above two great Sanskrit literatures can help you pigs to become human .
"The narcissist Prophet
"The narcissist Prophet lacked in judgment. The biggest mistake Muhammad made was to invent an ‘ungodly’ God. He was in such a delusion that he could not even differentiate between a God and a Demon."
I'm not sure Muhammad's invention of an "ungodly god" should be described as a mistake. The 'god' invent served muhammad perfectly.
Shafee al-Zindig wrote: Do
Shafee al-Zindig wrote:
Do any other readers feel the same about off-topic comments?
Shafee I just skip past the garbage that is posted here.
JAH, What studies are ou
JAH, What studies are ou talking about, we are in the 21st century, what happend in the BC happened in BC, welcome to 2009.
Then again JAH, go ahead rant
Then again JAH, go ahead rant and rave like a little spoiled brat, NOBODY GIVES A XXXX ABOUT YOUR XXXXXXXXX ANYMORE
@JAH, Why are you going to
@JAH,
Why are you going to US sources to get stats. You can get all types crime stats from Home Dept of India. It's called freedom of information act. You would not know what it means. You cannot get those stats in Islamic countries since crime is considered highest human conduct as per your Sunnah. As promised, you get reward in line with your Islamic traditions for every research you do. This time you get a new Mom. Your Dad is rewarded to have sex with your wife for giving birth to a pig like you and your wife becomes your new Mom.
A grand prize awaits for your next research work.
[...] here to see the
[...] here to see the original: BOOK REVIEW: UNDERSTANDING MUHAMMAD, A PSYCHOBIOGRAPHY | Faith … This entry is filed under Hindu, Om. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS [...]
People, I have realised ,my
People, I have realised ,my mistake and its best that we stick to debating Islam. By beating around the bush we are merely wasting our time.
Instead of answering the
Instead of answering the article this JAHanam muslim chose to attack hinduism. I don't see any hindu people who want to impose hinduism on others and they don't want to conquer the world or persecute non hindu. Answer the article, muslim!!!!!
there maybe some problems
there maybe some problems with gita and maybe not,but we chose to take good things out of gita....
like this quotation from gita...
from your action of today, your future is made....
and what you are today is because of your actions of the past...
this applies to all human beings on earth, whether they are hindus or not...
pakshaitan says. "there
pakshaitan says.
"there maybe some problems with gita and maybe not,but we chose to take good things out of gita…."
There is no problem in Gita. The problem is with JAH's evil muslim brain when he takes the verses of war out of context. The war of Mahabharat was like WWII where there were clearly good and evil sides. It was not Lord Krishna's war to control the Kingdom. Lord Krishna even vowed not to take up his weapon. Both warring parties were Hindus and loved Krishna. When the war over, the surviving relatives of Duryodhan (The Hitler of Mahabharat) lived happily with Pandavas. In fact the eldest Pandava - Yudhistir offered Duryodhan's Father to remain as the King.
If you go to the code of conduct in Mahabharat war, it will put Geneva convention to shame. Uttering a false word like Yudhistir did, was considered an act of unethical war behavior.
Do you want to compare civilized people's story to that of Pigs who covet for a world filled with shit?
WHO DO YOU PEOPLE THINK U
WHO DO YOU PEOPLE THINK U ARE? WHY ON EARTH ARE CRITICISING MUSLIMS FOR. I MEAN WHAT DO U HAVE AGAINST US ALL. I SWEAR IF I JUST KNEW WHO YOU WERE THEN I WOULD COME NOW WHEREVER YOU ALL ARE AND KICK THE SHIT OUT OF YOU ALL WITH MY ARMY. YOU UNDERSTAND. I JUST HATE IT. HOW WOULD YOU FEEL IF WE MUSLIMS TOOK THE PISS OUT OF YOUR RELIGION? WELL YOU KNOW WHAT US MUSLIMS NEVER SAY SHIT ABOUT OTHER RELIGIONS BECAUSE WE RESPECT ALL RELIGIONS. I AM REALLY PISSED AFF AT THE MOMENT BUT WHAT CAN I DO, I DON'T KNOW WHO YOU PEOPLE ARE. ANYWAYS I'LL JUST LEAVE IT TILL JUDGEMENT DAY WHERE ALL YOU BASTARDS WILL BURN LIKE SHIT AND WILL SAY TO ALLAH "PLEASE FORGIVE ME" BUT YOU KNOW WHAT THERE IS 1 IN 100 CHANCE OF HIM IN FORGIVING YOU. IF I READ ANOTHER COMMENT POSTED BY ANY OF YOU LOT CRITICISING ISLAM THEN EVEN WHEN I DON'T WANT TO I WILL CRITICISE ALL YOUR LOTS RELIGIONS. AND BY THE WAY I CAN FIND OUT WHERE EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOU LOT LIVES YOU BASTARDS.